Month: June 2025

Reading of the Week: PTSD Among 9/11 Responders – the New Nature Study; Also, Therapy Isn’t Psychotherapy and Physician Vacations & Burnout

June 19, 2025 /

From the Editor

He survived the car accident that killed his partner. Although he was physically unscathed, he struggled with PTSD, lucidly describing in our sessions the nightmares and fears that dominated his life.

How long do such symptoms last? Does time heal? Frank D. Mann (of Stony Brook University) and his co-authors attempt to answer these questions with a new study, one of the largest and longest on this disorder to date. In the first selection, we examine their Nature Mental Health paper, involving 13 000 responders to the World Trade Center attack, and spanning 20 years of data. “Our findings highlight the enduring impact of PTSD among World Trade Center responders, with substantial variability in individual trajectories. Despite overall modest declines, a subset remained highly symptomatic, underscoring the need for continued treatment.” We consider the paper and its implications.

In the second selection from Psychiatric News, Dr. Steven Reidbord, a psychiatrist based in San Francisco, notes the rising popularity of therapy and how things are changing with AI. But he suggests there is a difference between “corner-cutting” therapy and real psychotherapy, which is meant for personal change. “Psychotherapists must defend quality care against the seductive fictions that pervade social media. Our own message may be less alluring, but it has the advantage of being true…”

And in the third selection, Dr. Christine A. Sinsky (of the American Medical Association) and her co-authors look at physician vacations. Drawing on a national survey of US docs, they analyzed vacations, work during these vacations, and burnout. “These findings suggest that support for taking vacation and efforts to reduce physicians’ obligations to perform patient care-related tasks while on vacation, such as providing full electronic health record inbox coverage, should be considered to prevent physician burnout.”

Note that there will be no Readings for the next two weeks. (The discussion of vacations is inspiring.)

And, on a pivot, to those completing their residency education at the end of this month: all the best in your careers. Enjoy this remarkable moment.

DG

Continue reading

Reading of the Week: Suicide – with Papers from AJP and BJPsych Int; Also, O’Brien on His Brother’s Suicide & His Family

June 12, 2025 /

From the Editor

She came into our ED feeling overwhelmed. After a recent breakup, she felt suicidal; the academic demands of grade 12 further stressed her. As a clinician, this type of adolescent presentation seems to be increasingly common.

But is it? Many people have opinions. Dr. Tanner J. Bommersbach (of the University of Wisconsin) and his co-authors attempt to shed light on the state of teen mental health with a new and important paper focused on suicidal ideation, plans, and attempts. In the first selection, we examine their American Journal of Psychiatry paper, involving almost 120 000 high school students, drawing on US survey data, and covering a decade and a half. “In this nationally representative sample… significant increases occurred in the percentage reporting past-year suicidal thoughts, suicide plans, and suicide attempts from 2007 to 2021.” We consider the paper and its implications.

In the second selection from BJPsych International, Dr. Rachel Gibbons (of the Royal College of Psychiatrists) writes about suicide. In a controversial paper, she argues that we make too many assumptions about suicide, which colour our research and undermine our understanding of patients. “Embracing the complexity of suicide may not only refine prevention but also deepen our understanding of suffering, resilience, and meaning.”

And in the third selection, playwright Dan O’Brien writes about his brother’s suicide for Esquire. In a deeply personal essay, he discusses his brother’s mental health problems and his parents’ desire to hide them. He wonders what could have been. “I would like to be helpful to some who might read this, if only to deny that the suffering of mental illness is a disgrace, and to assert that such suffering is common and survivable.”

DG

Continue reading

Reading of the Week: Therapy = More Work + Better Income? The New Psych Medicine Study; Also, Zero Suicide & Melatonin for Kids

June 5, 2025 /

From the Editor

After completing a course of psychotherapy, he felt better and began a part-time job. The employment gave him a sense of purpose. As a physician, I could both sympathize and empathize; for many, work is a meaningful part of life, after all.

But does psychotherapy necessarily result in employment? Does therapy pay for itself with economic benefits? Otto R. F. Smith (of NLA University College) and his co-authors attempt to answer these questions in an impressive new paper in Psychological Medicine. They report on an RCT involving more than 700 Norwegian participants who were randomized to a psychotherapy program (modeled after the UK’s IAPT service) or to treatment as usual. The authors used administrative databases to analyze employment, income, and the economic benefit. “The results support the societal economic benefit of investing in IAPT-like services.” We consider the paper and its implications.

In the second selection, Dr. Calina Ouliaris (of Macquarie University) and her co-authors look at the zero suicide approach. In a Commentary for The British Journal of Psychiatry, they argue that – despite being studied and implemented in several places – it lacks evidence. “The Zero Suicide Framework is an arguably vague framework with a scant evidence base, particularly for application in healthcare settings. Despite this, the concrete goal championed… that of ‘zero suicides’, is appealing and has been widely promulgated in mental health services, ahead of evidence for the same.”

Finally, in the third selection, Dr. Chris Y. Kim (of the University of Toronto) and his co-authors weigh the use of melatonin for children and adolescents. In The Canadian Journal of Psychiatry, they are cautious, in part because of the lack of consistency of over-the-counter melatonin. “Melatonin used as a hypnotic agent for the treatment of insomnia is controversial.”

DG

Continue reading