Tag: Yang

Reading of the Week: Psychedelics vs Antidepressants – the New JAMA Psych Paper; Also, US Psilocybin Use and Hahn on the Work of Mental Illness

April 30, 2026 /

From the Editor

“Trump signs order to accelerate access to psychedelic drug treatments”

– Reuters, 18 April 2026

Last week, the U.S. president signed an executive order easing the way for more research on psychedelics for mental illness. It’s another example of the enthusiasm that many – policymakers, politicians, patients, families, members of the public – have for these drugs. Past work has indicated some effectiveness in treating depression. But how much of it can be explained by placebo? Psychedelics are, after all, challenging to study, in part because of difficulties with blinding (people can figure out whether they receive a psychedelic or placebo).

Dr. Zachary J. Williams (of the University of California, Los Angeles) and his co-authors attempt to shed light on this issue with a new, smart study published in JAMA Psychiatry. In it, they did a meta-analysis, comparing the effectiveness of psychedelic-assisted therapy (PAT) and open-label traditional antidepressants (TADs) for the treatment of major depression, drawing on 24 studies. “These findings suggest that PAT is no more effective than TADs under equal-unblinding conditions for the treatment of depression and highlight the potential role of blinding integrity.” We consider the paper and its implications.

And, on the topic of psychedelics, Dr. Kevin H. Yang (of the University of California, San Diego) and his co-authors look to quantify the number of people using psilocybin in the United States. In a priority data letter for The American Journal of Psychiatry, they used data from the National Survey on Drug Use and Health, a survey with more than 59 000 respondents. “With approximately 8 million individuals estimated as having used in the past year, naturalistic psilocybin use is sufficiently prevalent that psychiatrists are likely to encounter patients who use it outside of clinical settings.”

And in the third selection, an essay from The Globe and Mail, Brandon Hahn writes personally about his experiences with mental illness, noting public intolerance and tolerance – and meaningful gestures. “Sometimes support looks like red tape and a pile of forms. Sometimes it looks like a chair that faces the window while holding a hand.”

DG

Continue reading

Reading of the Week: Aromatherapy for Insomnia? Also, Ramadan and Mental Health and Responding to Vaccine History

April 15, 2021 /

From the Editor

“Sleep is one of the indispensable needs of human beings and is essential for maintaining physical and mental health.”

So writes Yueheng Tang (of the Huazhong University of Science and Technology) and co-authors in a new paper on insomnia. That topic is always relevant; with a third wave and the ongoing stresses of the pandemic, more people than ever seem to be struggling with insomnia. In the past few weeks, I’ve received a flurry of questions from patients and non-patients about remedies for insomnia.

What to make of aromatherapy? It’s trendy – but is it evidence based? In a new paper for the Journal of Affective Disorders, Tang et al. consider aromatherapy which “has a long history in China, and it has been used to strengthen the body and treat diseases since ancient times.” They conduct a meta-analysis, drawing on sixteen articles. They find: “Aromatherapy has a significant effect on improving sleep quality.” We consider the paper and ask: should we recommend this to our patients?

aromatherapy

In the second selection, we look at a new podcast that explores Ramadan and its clinical implications. In this Quick Takes episode, I’m joined by Drs. Juveria Zaheer and Zainab Furqan (both of the University of Toronto). They discuss fasting, mental disorders, and offer some suggestions. For example, with drug regiments: “if a medication is dosed twice daily, we can ask if it can be given safely during the interval when the interval between doses is shortened? So can we give it then in the evening or at dawn and then at sunset again? Or can we give it as one dose? And we need to think about the side effects of the medication.”

Finally, in our third selection, a reader writes us. Dr. Suze G. Berkhout (of the University of Toronto) responds to the paper by Drs. Angela Desmond and Paul A. Offit considering the history of vaccines. “The story the authors tell is history as it is written by the victors: emphasizing the hard work and successes of scientists, while failing to acknowledge the ways in which vaccine technologies have also been part of an exclusionary politics of biomedicine.”

Note that there will be no Reading next week.

DG

Continue reading